Ask an Expert
Not sure what you're looking at? Wondering if a locality is right, or how to clean a piece safely? Ask the EarthWonders expert panel — one question, one private chat.
Last updated
Ask a question
- 1
Click Ask an Expert
On a specimen page, Ask an Expert sits under the price and the buying buttons. Asking from there attaches that specimen's photo to your question. The ? next to it explains what the experts can help with.

- 2
Write your question
A new chat opens over the page, with the experts who will read it at the top. Type your question. Use + to add more photos or another specimen, or remove the attached one if your question is about something else.

- 3
Send it
Sending starts a private chat between you and every expert on the panel. It is listed in your Messages as “Ask an Expert · your name”, and each question you ask gets its own chat. Every expert receives your question with its photo, and any of them can answer.

- 4
Read the answer
The answer appears in the same chat, and the Messages button shows an unread badge. Reply there to follow up.

Not logged in? The button reads "Log in to ask an expert". Once you log in, your new question opens right where you left off.
Where to find Ask an Expert
On a specimen page
Under the price and the buying buttons. Your question starts with that specimen's photo attached.
Above the home feed
In the bar with Guides, Events, and Blog. Best for a general question that isn't about a listing.
In the menu
Open the menu and look under Help. It's there on every page.


When an expert answers
Replies arrive in Messages, like any other conversation, with the unread badge on the Messages button.
Any expert on the panel can reply, and more than one may join in. Reply in the same chat to follow up.
The chat is private: only you, the experts, and the EarthWonders team can read it.
In the EarthWonders app, your questions and answers are in Messages too, so you can read and reply from your phone.
Mark your question as resolved
Got your answer? Click Mark as resolved at the top of the chat and confirm. You or any expert can do it. A resolved question can't be reopened: the chat stays readable, the message box is replaced by "This question has been resolved.", and it shows a Resolved label in your Messages.

Ask an Expert or Support Chat?
Ask an Expert — about minerals
Identification, localities, crystal habits, treatments, care and cleaning, building a collection. Answered by the expert panel.
Support Chat — about EarthWonders
Orders, payments, payouts, your account, or something on the site that isn't working. Answered by the EarthWonders team.
Getting a great answer
Do
- Add sharp photos in daylight, from more than one side
- Say where it was found or bought, and what the label says
- Mention what you already think it is, and why
- Ask one question per chat — click Ask an Expert again for the next one
Don't
- Ask about orders, payments, or your account — Support Chat handles those
- Share phone numbers, addresses, or payment details
- Treat an answer as a formal appraisal or certificate of authenticity
Common questions
Does it cost anything?
No. Asking the experts is free, and you can ask as many questions as you like.
Who are the experts?
Experienced collectors, dealers, and mineral specialists whom the EarthWonders team invites to the panel. Their names and photos are shown at the top of a new question.
How soon will I get an answer?
Experts answer when they're available, so it can take a little while. The reply appears in your Messages, so you don't need to keep the chat open.
Can an expert value or authenticate my specimen?
An expert can share an informed opinion from your photos and description — what it probably is, signs of treatment or repair, what to check next. It is not a formal appraisal or certificate.
Can I reopen a resolved question?
No. A resolved question stays readable but closed for good. If you have a new question or a follow-up, click Ask an Expert again to start a new chat.
Who can see my question?
Only you, the experts on the panel, and the EarthWonders team. It never appears on your profile or anywhere public.